Tests Reveal Toxic ‘Forever Chemicals’ in Aerial Pesticide Showered Over Millions of Acres in US

“These findings shock the conscience.”

A plane sprays pesticide over the Wynwood neighborhood in the hope of controlling and reducing the number of mosquitos, some of which may be capable of spreading the Zika virus on August 6, 2016 in Miami, Florida. (Photo: Joe Raedle/Getty Images)
A plane sprays pesticide over the Wynwood neighborhood in the hope of controlling and reducing the number of mosquitos, some of which may be capable of spreading the Zika virus on August 6, 2016 in Miami, Florida. (Photo: Joe Raedle/Getty Images)

A national nonprofit revealed Tuesday that testing commissioned by the group as well as separate analysis conducted by Massachusetts officials show samples of an aerially sprayed pesticide used by the commonwealth and at least 25 other states to control mosquito-borne illnesses contain toxic substances that critics call “forever chemicals.”

“Communities are struggling to remove PFAS from their drinking water supplies, while at the same time, we may be showering them with PFAS from the skies and roads.”
—Kyla Bennett, PEER

Officially known as per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), this group of man-made chemicals—including PFOA, PFOS, and GenX—earned the nickname because they do not break down in the environment and build up in the body. PFAS has been linked to suppressed immune function, cancers, and other health issues.

Lawmakers and regulators at various levels of government have worked to clean up drinking water contaminated by PFAS. The newly released results of pesticide testing by Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility (PEER) and the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection (MADEP) generated alarm about the effectiveness of such efforts.

“In Massachusetts, communities are struggling to remove PFAS from their drinking water supplies, while at the same time, we may be showering them with PFAS from the skies and roads,” PEER science policy director Kyla Bennett, a scientist and attorney formerly with U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, said in a statement Tuesday.

Food & Water Watch
@foodandwater
NEW: @PEERorg found that toxic PFAS “forever chemicals” were sprayed on millions of acres in MA & 25 other states. PFAS are linked to cancer, liver issues & more. The @EPA must hold polluters accountable & clean up our drinking water NOW! @BostonGlobe
Toxic ‘forever chemicals’ found in pesticide used on millions of acres across the country. The compounds are found in a range of commercial products and never fully degrade. They have been linked to cancer, low infant birth weights, and a range of diseases.

“The frightening thing is that we do not know how many insecticides, herbicides, or even disinfectants contain PFAS,” added Bennett, who arranged for the testing. “PEER found patents showing chemical companies using PFAS in these products, and recent articles discuss the variety of pesticides that contain PFAS as either an active or an inert ingredient.”

The product tested initially by PEER and subsequently MADEP, once the nonprofit alerted the department of its findings, is Anvil 10+10, produced by the Illinois company Clarke.

The NY Environmental Law and Justice Project, in conjunction with the No Spray Coalition, succeeded in 2001 in getting the NYC government to fine Clarke Environmental $1 million, and blocked Clarke from being awarded a $277 million 3-year spray contract, for violations of worker health and safety during that year’s spraying.

Karen Larson, Clarke’s vice president of government affairs, told the Boston Globe that “when this was first brought to our attention, we conducted an internal inquiry of our manufacturing and supply chain to ensure that PFAS was not an ingredient in the production, manufacturing, or distribution of either the active or inactive ingredients of Anvil.”

“No PFAS ingredients are used in the formulation of Anvil, nor in the production of any source material in Anvil. PFAS components are not added at any point in the production of Anvil,” she said. Larson added that while it is unclear why the Clarke pesticide contained PFAS, the company “will continue to work closely with the EPA to conduct our own testing.”

PEER executive director Tim Whitehouse detailed the recent testing results in a letter (pdf) sent last week to MADEP Commissioner Martin Suuberg that called for halting the use of Anvil 10+10, ensuring any replacement does not contain forever chemicals, and requiring pesticide companies to comprehensively test their products for PFAS:

This fall, PEER conducted several tests for PFAS of a 2.5 gallon jug of Anvil 10+10, the pesticide used in the aerial spraying programs of Massachusetts and many other states. Our tests revealed that Anvil 10+10 contains roughly 250 parts per trillion (ppt) of perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA), and 260–500 ppt of hexafluoropropylene oxide dimer acid (HFPO-DA), a GenX replacement for PFOA. Both these results are hovering around the detection limits of the laboratory’s equipment, but there is no doubt that these PFAS are in the insecticide. While PFAS may be useful when added to pesticides as surfactants, dispersants, and anti-foaming agents, it is unclear whether the PFAS found in Anvil 10+10 is an ingredient added by the manufacturer, contained in one of the ingredients supplied to Anvil’s manufacturer by other companies, or whether it is a contaminant from the manufacturing/storage process. Moreover, since we were only able to test for 36 PFAS out of the 9,252 on the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA’s) inventory, it is impossible to know how many other PFAS might be in Anvil 10+10.

[…]

When PEER obtained its first positive PFAS results on Anvil 10+10, we immediately contacted DEP because of the far-reaching implications. MADEP independently tested nine samples of Anvil 10+10 from five different containers, and found eight different PFAS, including PFOA and PFOS. Some PFAS levels were over 700 ppt. As such, there appears to be no doubt that there are PFAS in the pesticide Massachusetts has chosen for mosquito control.

Whitehouse noted that Massachusetts aerially sprayed 2.2 million acres with Anvil 10+10 last year and more than 200,000 acres this year. The Globe explained that “most of the spraying has been done in the southeastern part of the state, where EEE, a rare but deadly mosquito-borne disease, has been most prevalent.”

The EPA, which has been lambasted by lawmakers as well as environmental and public health advocates for its handling of PFAS contamination on a national scale, is working on “an analytical method” to detect the forever chemicals in pesticides and plans to conduct its own tests of Anvil 10+10, according to the newspaper.

“There are significant unanswered questions about the data currently available,” Dave Deegan, a spokesperson for the federal agency’s offices in New England, told the Globe. “EPA will continue to work closely with and support the state on this issue. Aggressively addressing PFAS continues to be an important, active, and ongoing priority for EPA.”

“The EPA must ban all pesticides with PFAS components, designate PFAS as hazardous substances to hold polluters accountable for cleanup of contamination, and set strong enforceable standards for PFAS in our drinking water.”
—Wenonah Hauter, Food & Water Watch

Bennett and other critics of the EPA’s response to PFAS reiterated concerns about the agency in the wake of the revelations in Massachusetts.

“This PFAS fiasco shows that public trust in EPA having a full accounting of these materials and their safety is utterly misplaced,” said Bennett. “Until EPA acts, states need to adopt their own safeguards and chemical disclosure requirements because they certainly cannot depend upon the diligence of EPA.”

“In a statement about the testing on Tuesday, Food & Water Watch executive director Wenonah Hauter declared that “these findings shock the conscience—states likely have unknowingly contaminated communities’ water with PFAS hidden in pesticides. Once again, the EPA has failed to protect the American people from harmful pollution.”

Emphasizing that “we need to stop the introduction of toxic forever chemicals into the environment and our water sources to protect public health,” Hauter said that “the EPA must ban all pesticides with PFAS components, designate PFAS as hazardous substances to hold polluters accountable for cleanup of contamination, and set strong enforceable standards for PFAS in our drinking water.”

“The GOP-controlled Senate must step up and pass the PFAS Action Act, which passed the House in January, to regulated these toxic compounds and hold polluters accountable, and Congress must pass he WATER Act to provide the financial relief to community water providers and households with wells to remove PFAS from drinking water or find alternative sources where treatment fails,” she added. “Now is the time for decisive action to protect people’s health and safety.”
————————

TWENTY YEARS AND 3 MAYORS LATER

NYC’S GOVERNMENT again sprays the Bronx and other parts of the City with adulticides to kill mosquitoes, with no thought given to how the toxic … Read more

Join in! No Spray Webinar “Herbicides are Poisonous for Children and Other Living Things” Tuesday, Oct. 6th

Mark Your Calendar!   Herbicides Are Poisonous for Children & Other Living Things   WEBINAR: Tuesday, October 6, 2020, 8 p.m. EST, 7 pm Central … Read more

NYC Spraying Poisons in Brooklyn and Queens, Thursday, September 3rd –

Mayor Bill de Blasio’s administration continues the poisonous practices of its predecessors and resumes pesticide spraying in southern Brooklyn on Thursday, September 3, 2020, between … Read more

PESTICIDE SPRAYING IN BROOKLYN TUESDAY AUGUST 25, 2020

PESTICIDE SPRAYING IN BROOKLYN TUESDAY AUGUST 25, 2020

The deBlasio administration continues the poisonous practices of its predecessors and resumes pesticide spraying in southern Brooklyn. Tuesday, August 25, between the hours of 8:30 … Read more

Pesticide spraying in Staten Island Weds, August 12, 2020

Parts of Staten Island will undergo pesticide spraying on Wednesday as a part of the city government’s absurd goal to rid the five boroughs of … Read more

STOP SPRAYING MOSQUITO PESTICIDES — A MESSAGE FROM OUR SISTER GROUP “BEYOND PESTICIDES”

STOP SPRAYING MOSQUITO PESTICIDES — A MESSAGE FROM OUR SISTER GROUP “BEYOND PESTICIDES”

  TAKE ACTION! Tell Public Officials to Stop Mosquito Spraying and Adopt a Safe, Effective Mosquito Management Plan Does your community spray toxic pesticides for mosquitoes? … Read more

NYC to Spray Toxic Poisons in Brooklyn and Queens August 29th

NYC to Spray Toxic Poisons in Brooklyn and Queens August 29th

From No Spray Coordinator Mitchel Cohen: I just checked the street poles around a park near my apartment in the spray zone where little kids … Read more

For 20th Year, New York City Continues Toxic and Indiscriminate Pesticide Spray Program – Queens, The Bronx to be Sprayed August 15

For 20th Year, New York City Continues Toxic and Indiscriminate Pesticide Spray Program – Queens, The Bronx to be Sprayed August 15

No Spray Coalition Took NYC to Court to Stop Spraying Under Mayor Rudolph Giuliani in 2000 When Will it End? No Review of the West … Read more

No Spray’s Mitchel Cohen on Book Tour in California to Support “The Fight Against Monsanto’s Roundup” – August Dates

No Spray’s Mitchel Cohen on Book Tour in California to Support “The Fight Against Monsanto’s Roundup” – August Dates

No Spray Coalition Coordinator Mitchel Cohen will be speaking at these book events discussing his recent release, “The Fight Against Monsanto’s Roundup: The Politics of … Read more

No Spray Coalition to Host Panel “The Politics of Pesticides” at Left Forum NYC Friday, June 28

No Spray Coalition to Host Panel “The Politics of Pesticides” at Left Forum NYC Friday, June 28

No Spray Coalition hosts a panel at the 2019 Left Forum Friday, June 28th at 5 p.m.: “The Politics of Pesticides: Some Things Leftists Don’t … Read more

The unseen carcinogenic danger lurking in New York City’s public parks – The Guardian

The unseen carcinogenic danger lurking in New York City’s public parks – The Guardian

The unseen carcinogenic danger lurking in New York City’s public parks Opinion piece by Ben Kallos, June 6, 2019, The Guardian City councilman Ben Kallos … Read more

MONSANTO’S SMOKING GUN – MISSED BY THE PRESS

MONSANTO’S SMOKING GUN – MISSED BY THE PRESS

by Jim Mann What would the public think about a multi-billion dollar conglomerate that filed a bogus lawsuit against a frail and elderly 80 year-old … Read more

New Book: The Fight Against Monsanto’s Roundup: The Politics of Pesticides by No Spray Coalition’s Mitchel Cohen

New Book: The Fight Against Monsanto’s Roundup: The Politics of Pesticides by No Spray Coalition’s Mitchel Cohen

THE FIGHT AGAINST MONSANTO’S ROUNDUP The Politics of Pesticides Written and edited by M i t c h e l     C o h e … Read more

Study: You are not Gluten Intolerant; You are Glyphosate Intolerant

Study: You are not Gluten Intolerant; You are Glyphosate Intolerant

Study blames Roundup herbicide for gluten intolerance and celiac disease epidemic From Get Holistic Health: “Celiac disease, and, more generally, gluten intolerance, is a growing … Read more

Coconut-Derived Insect Repellent More Effective Than Hazardous DEET

Coconut-Derived Insect Repellent More Effective Than Hazardous DEET

Coconut-Derived Insect Repellent More Effective than the Hazardous DEET Via Beyond Pesticides, November 6, 2018 Scientists working for USDA’s Agricultural Research Service in Lincoln, Nebraska … Read more

New Mosquito Spraying “Events”: Toxic Pesticides to be Sprayed by Truck August 22 & 23 in Queens, Bronx, Brooklyn (2X)

New Mosquito Spraying “Events”: Toxic Pesticides to be Sprayed by Truck August 22 & 23 in Queens, Bronx, Brooklyn (2X)

Bronx map of areas for pesticide spraying[/caption]Yet again, New York City will be spraying dozens of neighborhoods across three boroughs with toxic pesticides on Wednesday, … Read more

Staten Island to be Sprayed with Toxic Pesticides This Evening, August 16th; In Four Boroughs Larvaciding by Helicopter Aug. 16, 17, 20

Staten Island to be Sprayed with Toxic Pesticides This Evening, August 16th; In Four Boroughs Larvaciding by Helicopter Aug. 16, 17, 20

New York City has scheduled pesticide spraying by truck this evening, Thursday, August 16th between 9 p.m. and 6 a.m. in Staten Island. Areas to … Read more

New York City Spraying Harmful & Carcinogenic Pesticides in Brooklyn Tonight | Unchecked Spray “Program” Now in 19th Year

New York City Spraying Harmful & Carcinogenic Pesticides in Brooklyn Tonight | Unchecked Spray “Program” Now in 19th Year

When will this toxic pesticide spraying end? Large sections of Brooklyn will be sprayed this evening, August 9th. The pesticide spraying program for West Nile … Read more

Rachel Carson on Malathion, “Dangerous Interactions” between Pesticides

Rachel Carson on Malathion, “Dangerous Interactions” between Pesticides

An important note from Rachel Carson’s seminal book, Silent Spring, released in 1962: A NOTE FROM RACHEL CARSON Malathion, another of the organic phosphates, is … Read more

No Spray Coalition Condemns De Blasio Admin for Toxic Pesticide Spraying; 18th Year of Harmful Spraying for West Nile Virus

No Spray Coalition Condemns De Blasio Admin for Toxic Pesticide Spraying; 18th Year of Harmful Spraying for West Nile Virus

Pesticide Spraying Harms Human Health, Animals, Beneficial Insects, Entire Eco System   The New York City Department of Health began its 18th year of pesticide … Read more

SPRAY VS. NO SPRAY: Comparative Analysis of 14 Cities Which Spray Pesticides for West Nile Virus Vs. Those That Don’t

SPRAY VS. NO SPRAY: Comparative Analysis of 14 Cities Which Spray Pesticides for West Nile Virus Vs. Those That Don’t

Analysis shows no Increase in Occurrence of West Nile Virus in Cities That Do Not Spray Pesticides The No Spray Nashville group analyzed data based … Read more

Victory! Oregon County Votes to Ban Aerial Pesticide Spraying

Victory! Oregon County Votes to Ban Aerial Pesticide Spraying

Lincoln County (Oregon) Bans Aerial Pesticide Spraying Voters vote YES on Measure 21-177 in narrow victory over pesticide companies First electoral ban of pesticides in … Read more

“Beneficial” Insects act as Alternative to Harmful & Toxic Pesticides

“Beneficial” Insects act as Alternative to Harmful & Toxic Pesticides

At the No Spray Coalition, we try to be inclusive to all beings while recognizing that there are instances where some are more “wanted” than … Read more

NYC STILL USING PESTICIDES DESPITE LAW BANNING THEM

NYC STILL USING PESTICIDES DESPITE LAW BANNING THEM

City Still Using Pesticides Despite 2005 Law Banning Them By Elah Feder | August 10, 2015 City Limits JJ Harrison Anvil 10+10, the insecticide used … Read more